Usually I have the good sense to ignore self-righteous bad mouthing in comments but I slipped during the last couple of weeks.  Actually  I made some darn good points and clarified my believes during the exchanges , not that anyone was convinced.  In that sense, it was a complete  exercise in futility.

After writing an article on beautiful insights by Pope Francis on the nature of the Church, I am still appalled, two weeks later by those who misinterpret the pope . These people would love to stone  anyone who disagrees with them, labelling them as sinners, then burn  heretics at the stake and throw out our Spirit filled pope. When I mentioned gospel  attitudes of mercy and forgiveness, I was accused of being a modernist heretic who refuses to stand up for the Catholic Church, a writer who should be banned from CatholicLane.

My main point is that Jesus never commanded his followers to go around pointing out the sins, faults, short comings or failures of others. The only role that pointing out sin plays is to point to Christ’s redemptive act because sin no longer has any power over us. GOD’S CHOSEN ONES had 5,000 years of pointing out sin under the law of Moses AND IT DIDN’T SAVE ANYONE.  It’s awareness of God’s love and salvation for all that saves man.

To the rigid  purists  who think POPE FRANCIS is destroying the Roman Catholic Church:

As we observe this new pope,  I find that it is best to discern what is in the Lord with an open heart, and not with an eye that looks for mistakes. It is interesting to note that Jesus constantly upset the religious experts of his day by seeming to break the letter of the law when in fact, as Love incarnate, He was the fulfilment of the law. Also, Jesus constantly appeared to contradict Himself for those who judged His words only by their surface meaning. Many of Christ’s words seem difficult to reconcile if they are not read spiritually. I find the same holds true with Pope Francis.

In addition, an open, compassionate, INCLUSIVE attitude to “outsiders” does not mean the pope is rejecting the reality of the Body of Christ, or that he does not believe that the Catholic Church holds the fullness of truth. He is building bridges. No one ever saved a non believer by throwing stones of condemnation. with a self-righteous attitude. Jesus was also accused of rejecting the holy, chosen people of God , who obeyed God’s rules, when he hung out with outsiders.

Not all the pope’s prayers, thoughts, intents, actions, words.or letters  make it to the news. We are not privy to his heart’s intent. We are not privy to what God is telling him to do. We cannot judge;  it is impossible to assume that the pope is doing nothing behind the scenes, demanding that the public be informed of all complicated negotiations or correspondence. You can’t assume the worst. It would be more efficacious to pray that he does the will of God


  1. Wonderful, wonderful article Melanie, and for the bravery of telling it. There is no answer that will satisfy bigots. The sadness is that you have been subjected to their unchristian vitriol. The church did not start at the Council of Trent but by those who knew and loved Jesus and his message of compassion and love… and Pope Francis embodies this in his attempts to reconcile. I tend to avoid posting in areas that attract such followers. And they could never understand and see with the compassion that runs through your articles.


  2. The Pope said he is a son of the Church, I trust that he is. I heard someone compare Pope Benedict XVl and Pope Francis to St. Peter and St. Paul, one was a Scholar and one was a Fisherman. I believe it is a matter of style that is not comfortable to some. I enjoy your blog very much!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.