Trusting in 2,000 Years of Experience

When I became a Catholic at 19, I was overjoyed to discover a wealth of wisdom and teaching on prayer, spirituality and the faith. It was like unlocking a door to a d95459b24af2256197fd69239f1914fevast library of  information that had been kept hidden from me . This was information that I could count on, that I could trust as authentic, tried and true. This treasure trove of instruction had passed the test of time, the test of the saints and the experts.  I realized that as a Protestant who relied solely on sacred scripture, I had basically thrown out 2,000 years of the faith experiences of those who had gone before me.

Even the Bible itself says that it has recorded only a fraction of everything that Jesus said and did. Yet I was denying the veracity of anything that was not in the Bible. I had experienced hearing the voice of God within my heart but I was refusing to listen to thousands of years of divine revelation given to the saints and tested by those who could be trusted to discern those divine revelations.

I slowly came to understand that God gave full authority to his Son, Jesus Christ, who in turn, gave full authority to Peter and the Apostles when he told Peter that he would build his church upon him and gave him the keys to the kingdom. (Matthew 16:18–19). This means that I can freely place my trust in the Church, which speaks and acts with the authority that comes from God through Jesus Christ.  I finally learned how to lean on this tradition after years of inner turmoil about the role of the Blessed Virgin Mary in my life.

Naturally, as a former Protestant I  struggled with the spiritual reality of Mary. So, while I ranted against her, Mary simply decided to grab my attention by moving into my heart. Hilariously, I felt guilty about my relationship with the Blessed Virgin, almost like a heretic for 10 years after I became a Catholic because she had a relationship with me that I thought was wrong. I became a Catholic anyway because I was starving to receive the Eucharist and did not fit anywhere but in the Catholic Church.  Finally a dear friend, Fr. Robert Pelton, who was Director General of priests at Madonna House in Combemere, Ontario, Canada said,

Melanie, why don’t you just rest for a while by putting your trust in the teachings of the Church. Trust in the wisdom of thousands of years of experience and simply enjoy the wonderful gift your Heavenly Mother has given you. Put this theoretical debate on the back-burner.


Thank God for this priest. Thank God for tradition and thank God that I did not have to figure out everything on my own. When I stopped the inner  sophistry, the endless debates that circled in my brain, then the Holy Spirit had a chance to confirm everything that tradition taught me.

Every  newborn Christian does not have to reinvent the wheel; they have a treasure trove of wisdom to lean on, to guide and teach them.

6 thoughts on “Trusting in 2,000 Years of Experience

  1. I cannot thank you enough for this blog message today!! The Holy Spirit led me into the Catholic Church first (almost 2 years ago). And now–praise God–my husband, oldest son and wife, and our youngest son are in RCIA. My husband in particular is and has always struggled with the Mariology in the Church– He has huge issues with how she is viewed.. But, he has always respected her as the mother of Jesus. That being said, I KNOW that it will be a work of the Spirit (and intercession of Mary!) that can only draw him in. I covet your prayers for my family. I have found many a precious, precious jewel in my conversion. Thanks be to God. And thank you.


    1. For me, there was a deep rooted aversion to Mary that only God could dismantle. There are hilarious stories by people like Scott Hahn who were determined to show that Mary was a heresy but they ended up converting


      1. What seems like a mountain to us is nothing for God. He can grant insight and deliver someone in the snap of a finger. As St. Francis says, ” All the darkness in the world cannot extinguish the light of a single candle”. and your prayers shine like a beacon on your loved ones…sounds like what has happened in your family is already miraculous. No worries, just let go of control so God is free to move


  2. What a wonderful article Melanie. It is truly a blessing. I am learning so much, sometimes I can’t take it all in. I want to walk by faith. I love the idea of 2,000 years of the Holy Spirit working, and the information has been tested by the Church. AWESOME.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.